World Of Wanderlust

New York City will always leave you amazed. The towering skyscrapers reflect the sun’s bright rays, people hustle through busy streets, and chic cafes spread the aroma of freshly brewed coffee. There’s so much to discover, especially when it comes to food. You’ll find star-rated restaurants, new cafes popping up, and charming bakeries waiting for you. But if you want to avoid long lines and trendy spots, these hidden gem restaurants in New York City are perfect for you.

These lesser-known eateries, from family-run to more upscale spots, stay off most people’s radars. Not many have heard about these places, yet they offer incredible culinary experiences. Here are ten amazing hidden gem restaurants in New York you should definitely try.

Hidden Gem Restaurants in New York City – Summary

1. Sonnyboy
2. Cafe Cluny
3. Rintintin
4. Suited
5. El Sabroso
6. Sakagura
7. Sushi Mercer 295
8. Lee Lee’s Baked Goods
9. Le French Diner
10. Gaia Italian Cafe

Sonnyboy

Start your New York City adventure with a hearty breakfast at Sonnyboy. If you love poached eggs, French toast, and hot coffee, this Australian eatery redefines what a perfect brunch should be. The classic brunch menu includes poached eggs, eggs Benedict, French toast, and their best-selling folded eggs. At night, Sonnyboy transforms into a bar, serving delightful cocktails.

Located in the Lower East Side, Sonnyboy is a small restaurant with a cozy wooden interior and warm ambiance. They also have outdoor seating, perfect for people-watching while enjoying your meal. Though it seems busy, Sonnyboy is still one of NYC’s hidden gems.

Cafe Cluny

Visiting West Village feels like stepping into a movie set with its charming Federal-style buildings and cobblestone streets. After a long walk, drop by Cafe Cluny, a small restaurant inside an earth-colored building that exudes cozy vibes. It’s one of the most interesting hidden gem restaurants in the West Village.

Cafe Cluny offers a French-inspired menu with delicious options like short ribs, club sandwiches, healthy granola mix, and flavorful omelets. It’s a classic Western restaurant beloved for its brunch dishes.

Suited

A visit to the NYC Financial District can be quite an experience. Amidst towering skyscrapers and iconic statues, grab a coffee and bagel at Suited. This aesthetically pleasing cafe shows you how to start the day in the Financial District. With large windows, a white-dominated interior, and bright display cabinets, it’s a great spot for a morning latte crafted by American coffee expert Andrew Fazio. Suited also offers brunch items from muffins to full breakfasts. Despite being situated in a busy area, it remains a hidden gem.

Rintintin

Rintintin brings the Mediterranean to New York City. Whether you crave a fresh Greek salad or warm socca, this spot has you covered. It’s also a local favorite for brunch with options like egg toast and tuna carpaccio. With quirky decor, including posters and Mediterranean sea pictures, Rintintin offers a unique dining experience. At night, flickering neon lights create a different ambiance.

El Sabroso

El Sabroso truly defines the term ‘hidden gem.’ Tucked inside a freight elevator entrance in the Garment District, this restaurant offers tasty and affordable Ecuadorian dishes. Try the pollo guisado (chicken stew) or costillas al horno (baked ribs) at just $6 per plate. It’s a local favorite for quick, budget-friendly meals served in a small dining area.

Sakagura

If you enjoy hunting for hidden gem restaurants, Sakagura should be on your list. This Japanese eatery is hidden in the basement of a building at 211 E. 43rd St. The dimly lit interior features bamboo decorations and over 300 varieties of sake. Sakagura serves classic Japanese dishes, including fresh sushi, cold soba, and signature braised pork belly.

Sushi 295 Mercer

Another hidden gem is Sushi 295 Mercer, a small parlor offering the freshest sushi imported from Japan and New Zealand. This spot features top-quality nigiri, salmon rolls, and more. It’s also ideal for takeout if you want something delicious on the go.

Lee Lee’s Baked Goods

Founded in 1988 and located in Harlem, Lee Lee’s Baked Goods is a humble, authentic bakery. Its cozy interior boasts floral wallpaper, old photos, and a display cabinet filled with buttery pastries and delightful cookies. Their signature rugelach, with its crunchy dough and cinnamon toppings, is a must-try.

Le French Diner

For a taste of authentic French cuisine, visit Le French Diner. This small, unassuming restaurant has a charming dining area with fewer than five seats and a bar showcasing fantastic European wines. Enjoy dishes like escargots, fresh oysters, and crispy octopus, paired with a fine wine.

Gaia Italian Cafe

If you’re craving Italian food, Gaia Italian Cafe offers hearty home-cooked dishes from gnocchi to fresh-baked pizza. Located in a hidden spot on E. Houston, it remains one of NYC’s hidden gems for Italian cuisine.

New York City’s hidden gem restaurants are fantastic to explore. Whether you’re planning a hidden gem food-hunt on your next trip or want a local friend to show you around, these spots are truly worth a visit. Enjoy the culinary adventures that await you in the Big Apple!